Friends & Family Event: Save up to 30% Sitewide*
New favorite formula 20% off

Think Big All-in-One Mascara

Achieves lift, length, and volume while supporting longer, stronger looking lashes.

4.6
Rated 4.6 out of 5 stars
217 Reviews
$30 $24 20% savings
Size
Purchase
SAVE 10% ON FUTURE SUBSCRIPTIONS
Benefits
  • Volumize
  • Lengthen
  • Condition
  • Long Wear

Enhance your lashes with this high-performance mascara that delivers dramatic lift, length, and bold volume. Powered by lash-conditioning plant waxes Carnauba and Candelilla to support longer, fuller, stronger looking lashes and a weightless feel.

logo of a leaping bunny
EWG Verified logo with text 'For Your Health' and website 'EWG.org'.

Learn about our certifications

Spend & Save

With every $200 spent, earn $15 in product credit toward your next purchase.

Learn more Sign in
Clinically Demonstrated:
  • Smudge-proof*
  • Longwear formula**
Immediate results***:
  • [ 97% ] experienced fuller lashes
  • [ 97% ] experienced thicker looking lashes
  • [ 97% ] experienced visibly defined & separated lashes
After just four weeks****:
  • [ 97% ] experienced fuller looking lashes
  • [ 97% ] experienced thicker looking lashes
  • *Based on a 30-subject clinical study.
  • **Based on a 30-subject clinical study after 6 hours.
  • ***Based on a 32 subject consumer perception study immediately after use.
  • ****Based on a 32 subject consumer perception study after four weeks of use.

Formulation Fact 01

We don’t formulate with PFAS like Polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE) - “forever chemicals” that can accumulate in our bodies and have been linked to cancer, weakened immune systems, reproductive and developmental harm, and hormone disrupting effects.

Displays a close up of a model's face.

Formulation Fact 02

We don’t formulate with ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid (EDTA) salts such as Disodium EDTA, Trisodium EDTA or Tetrasodium EDTA. Manufacturing EDTA and its salts involves reacting ethylenediamine, a harmful substance associated with reproductive toxicity. Unfortunately, EDTA and its salts may contain trace amounts of this substance. EDTA and its salts are also persistent and can harm the environment.

Displays a model in the process of applying a white Counter Cream to her face.

Formulation Fact 03

Formulated without heavily ethoxylated ingredients Polysorbate 60, Laureth 21, PEG-100 Stearate, and PEG-200 Glyceryl Stearate that carry particular risk for carcinogenic contaminants, ethylene oxide and 1,4-dioxane. We take ingredient purity seriously.

Displays a close up of a model's face.

Formulation Fact 04

We chose not to formulate our mascara with hair growth actives, prostaglandin and prostaglandin analogues like Ethyl Tafluprostamide, Isopropyl cloprostenate and Cloprostenol Ethyl Amide, which are endocrine active and can be linked to hyperpigmentation and periorbital fat atrophy.

Displays a close up of a model's face.
    4.6
    Rated 4.6 out of 5 stars
    Based on 217 reviews
    Reviews Summary
    Customers say this mascara lengthens and thickens lashes while providing excellent coverage without clumping. Many reviews mention its smooth application and all-day staying power. Users frequently praise its gentle formula, particularly noting comfort for sensitive eyes. The water-resistant formula stays put during activities but removes easily with makeup remover. Common feedback includes appreciation for the brush design and natural-looking results. While most reviews are overwhelmingly positive, some mention occasional smudging under eyes or difficulty with removal. A few customers note the reformulated version feels different from the original product.
    Search
    Search Reviews
    Rating
    Ratings
    Your skin tone:
    Your skin tone:
    Your undertone:
    Your undertone:
    How would you describe the texture/finish?
    How would you describe the texture/finish?
    How often do you use makeup?
    How often do you use makeup?
    Age
    Age
    217 reviews
    • Belinda H.
      Verified Buyer
      I recommend this product
      Age 65+
      Your skin tone: Light
      Your undertone: Not Sure
      How would you describe the texture/finish? Buildable
      How often do you use makeup? Rarely (0-1 days/week)
      Rated 5 out of 5 stars
      5/6/26
      Charcoal bar!

      Please, please, please bring back the charcoal bar! My whole family uses it & we are almost finished with our bars! It's been great on my face!

      So far I really like the mascara!!

      Thank you,

      Belinda

      Was this helpful?
    • Josephine K.
      Verified Buyer
      I recommend this product
      Age 65+
      How would you describe the texture/finish? Natural
      How often do you use makeup? Daily
      Rated 5 out of 5 stars
      5/1/26
      think big mascara

      I like this mascara because it doesn't clump!

      Was this helpful?
    • Rebekah B.
      Verified Buyer
      I recommend this product
      Age 35-44
      Rated 5 out of 5 stars
      4/25/26
      My favorite mascara

      Love, love, love!

      Was this helpful?
    • Delia J.
      Verified Buyer
      I recommend this product
      Age 65+
      Your skin tone: Medium
      Your undertone: Warm
      How would you describe the texture/finish? Natural
      How often do you use makeup? Daily
      Rated 5 out of 5 stars
      4/24/26
      Think big mascara

      I love how long my lashes look with just a few strokes.

      Was this helpful?
    • Holly H.
      Verified Buyer
      I recommend this product
      Age 45-54
      Your skin tone: Light
      Your undertone: Warm
      How would you describe the texture/finish? Lightweight
      How often do you use makeup? Frequent User (3-5 days/week)
      Rated 5 out of 5 stars
      4/21/26
      My favorite mascara

      I have read about all of the unhealthy and harmful ingredients in other mascaras and wouldn't dare want to use any of those. I do wish they had a brown mascara.

      Was this helpful?
    Show More

    WHAT'S IN AND WHAT'S NOT

    Learn about The Never List® & our Ingredient Philosophy

    We are what we do

    Discover who we are together

    Make more of your story

    Learn how to become a brand partner
    Displays a model covering half of her face with her hand. On her hand is the white smear of a Counter product.
    Displays the black and white profile of a model.

    Join Our Mailing List

    Sign Up for Emails

    By clicking “Sign Up”, I agree to receive email marketing from Counter at my email address and agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.